Friction: Da Vinci revisited

1 March 2018

The concept of friction was already investigated five hundred years ago by Leonardo da Vinci. His most important result, the proportionality of friction to normal force, is still used extensively today. UvA researchers, in collaboration with colleagues from Germany, have now shown that nevertheless, Da Vinci’s relation does not always accurately describe reality. Their results have been published in Nature Communications this week.

Friction is responsible for about twenty percent of the world energy consumption. The main reason for this is that frictional forces slow down the motion of surfaces in contact: think of the moving parts in a car engine. Over five hundred years ago, Leonardo da Vinci was the first person to study friction systematically. Da Vinci’s main result is still used today by many engineers: friction is proportional to the normal force. That is: when two objects are pressed together twice as hard, the friction also doubles. Researchers of the UvA Institute of Physics, the UvA Van ’t Hoff Institute for Molecular Sciences, the MicroTribology Center µTC in Freiburg and the Karlsruhe Institute of Technology have now studied this proportionality between friction and normal force more closely, using molecules that luminesce under pressure.

Surface roughness

In understanding friction, the concept of surface roughness plays a crucial role. On a molecular scale, almost all surfaces are rough: from nearby, such a surface looks like a mountainous landscape. Friction only arises at the locations where the highest hilltops on the two sliding surfaces touch one another.

To study this process in detail, the researchers designed a model experiment where a rough spherical surface was put into contact with a flat glass surface. The special feature of this experiment was that a single layer of contact sensitive dye molecules was added to the glass surface. These molecules emit fluorescent light when pressure is applied to them. This allowed the researchers to very precisely map out where the rough spherical surface touched the flat glass surface (see side bar image) and how the contact changed when more pressure was applied.

Friction experiment

The experimental setup. A rough plastic sphere is pressed against a flat glass surface. The pressure sensitive molecules on the glass surface luminesce when the spherical surface touches them. The fluorescent light emitted by the molecules is observed through the glass plate using a microscope.

When a larger normal force (pressure) is applied, the ‘hilltops’ on the spherical surface are flattened more, resulting in a larger contact area between the sphere and the glass plate. The usual interpretation of Da Vinci’s proportionality between friction and normal force is that both forces are proportional to this contact area: applying twice the pressure results in twice the contact area, and therefore in twice the friction. Several theories predict the relation between contact area and normal force, but so far these theories could not be tested with high precision. The researchers now show that the existing theories fall short: friction is proportional to the area of contact, as expected, but the contact area turns out not to be proportional to the normal force.

New models

The research results show that a better understanding of friction requires changes in the existing models, so that the measured relation between contact area and normal force can be reproduced. The results have been published this week in Nature Communications.

Reference

Molecular probes reveal deviations from Amontons’ law in multi-asperity frictional contacts, B. Weber, T. Suhina, T. Junge, L. Pastewka, A. M. Brouwer and D. Bonn, Nature Communications volume 9, Article number: 888 (2018)

Published by  IOP